If you’ve spent the past few years preparing for an inevitable roof replacement, you’ve probably started putting some money aside and have been keeping your eyes peeled for any leaks. Now that it’s getting closer to when you’ll need to schedule that new roof installation, you might be wondering if you should stick with asphalt shingles or try something new and go with metal.

This cost guide for homeowners will help you learn the average cost of metal roofs vs shingles. Plus, we’ll explore some pros and cons of each material to help you choose what’s best for your home.

Average Cost per Square Foot: Metal vs. Asphalt Shingles

cost of metal roof vs shingle metal

The average cost of metal roofing is $6.50-12.00 per square foot installed, while the average cost of asphalt shingles is $3-5 per square foot installed. The total price will obviously be higher if you have a large roof, but metal roofs tend to be more expensive than shingles on a per-square-foot basis.

Most roofing contractors order materials in “squares.” One roofing square = 100 square feet. Depending on the size of your roof, your contractor will order the appropriate amount of squares for your roof.

Average Total Roof Replacement Costs

When you hire a professional, you won’t only pay for the materials. You’ll also be paying for:

  • The tear-off of your old roof
  • Skilled labor
  • The installation of flashing, vents, gutters, etc.
  • Disposal of old roofing materials
  • Building permits (may not be necessary in all areas)
  • Clean up

The typical metal roof will cost anywhere from $10,000 to $30,000, while the asphalt shingle roof will cost between $5,000 and $18,000. The total price obviously depends on the size of your roof and the contractor you hire.

Why are metal roofs more expensive?

The main reason metal roofs are more expensive is that they last much longer than shingles. A metal roof can last 40-70 years, while an asphalt shingle roof will only last 15-25 years.

You might be thinking that you’ll just have to replace your metal roof sooner or later anyway, but that’s not necessarily true. Many metal roofs come with a warranty that will cover repairs and replacement for a certain number of years.

Pros and Cons: What Should You Choose?

cost of metal roof vs shingle asphalt

Asphalt shingles and metal roofing dominate the residential roofing world. While asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material across the country, metal roofing is quickly growing in popularity. Both materials offer benefits and disadvantages— check out the pros and cons to get a clearer picture of what each material offers.

✅ Asphalt Shingle Pros

  • As one of the more affordable roofing materials, asphalt shingles are achievable for many different income levels.
  • They’re easy to install and come in a variety of colors and styles.
  • Asphalt shingles are also one of the most lightweight roofing materials, which is good news for your home’s structural integrity.
  • If you live in an area with severe weather conditions, asphalt shingles can be a good choice because they’re wind resistant and can withstand gusts of up to 110 mph.
  • Since shingles are the most-used roofing material, they’re the standard for almost every roofing company. You’ll be hard-pressed to find a professional roofer that doesn’t know how to install asphalt shingles.

❌ Asphalt Shingle Cons

  • Asphalt shingles are not as durable as metal roofs and need to be replaced more often since they normally last 15-20 years.
  • They’re also not as energy efficient as metal roofs and can cause your energy bills to go up in the summer months.
  • Asphalt shingles are also more susceptible to fire damage than metal roofs.
  • They’re not as environmentally friendly since old roofing materials usually end up in landfills without getting recycled.

✅ Metal Roof Pros

  • Metal roofs are very durable and can last 40-70 years with proper maintenance.
  • They’re also very energy efficient and can help keep your energy bills down in both the winter and summer months.
  • Metal roofs are also fire resistant, which is a major plus if you live in an area with severe weather conditions.
  • They have a low-maintenance nature that doesn’t require a lot of extra upkeep for homeowners.
  • Metal roofs can be manipulated to look like many other popular roofing materials like shingles, tiles, and shakes. Standing seam panels also offer a sleek, aesthetically pleasing look.
  • Their longevity increases home value.

❌ Metal Roof Cons

  • The main downside of metal roofing is the initial cost. Metal roofs are more expensive than asphalt shingles, but they’re also more durable and offer more benefits in the long run.
  • Metal roofs can also be a little noisier in the rain, but this can be remedied with insulation.
  • Another downside of metal roofing is that it’s not as easy to install as asphalt shingles. You’ll need to hire a professional roofer who has experience installing metal roofs.

The bottom line is that both metal roofs and asphalt shingles have their pros and cons. It’s important to weigh all of your options before making a decision. Consider your budget, the climate you live in, the style of your home, how long you plan to live in your home, and the amount of maintenance you’re willing to do. With all of these factors in mind, you’ll be able to choose the roofing material that’s right for you.

We’ll Install a Long-Lasting Roof, No Matter What You Choose

At the end of the day, you get to choose if you want to pay more upfront for a metal roof that lasts longer or less money upfront for an asphalt roof that doesn’t last as long. Both material options are great choices for homeowners.

When it’s time for a new asphalt or metal roof in Ohio, be sure to work with the highly-rated team at Gouge Quality Roofing. Our expert team has years of experience installing both asphalt and metal roofs. Reach out today to get a free price quote for either material!